Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

advertise with us
Sponsored by
Read more about on-line and in print,
advertising or call 01723 363636 now.
 
 
Monday, 21st July 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scarborough Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Battle to stop super clinics



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 16 May 2008
A CAMPAIGN group opposing plans to set up a new 'supersurgery' in Scarborough is urging others to join the protest.
"Save Our GP Surgeries" members will be circulating a petition against the centre earmarked near the town centre as part of a Government shake-up in community health care.

The polyclinic, or 'Darzi centre,' is expected to be up and running by the beginning of May next year with an all-under-one-roof service 12 hours a day, seven days a week, including GPs – as well as homeless assistance, drugs and other substance misuse counselling, and sexual health problems.

Scarborough GPs say the new centre has been imposed without public consultation and in a letter in the Evening News appealed to residents to support them.

It states that "a large sum of money is to be squandered on a scheme that will do nothing to improve the health of Scarborough residents".

They are concerned that funding will be directed away from existing services – ultimately phasing out or undermining the town's local surgeries, as well as outpatient day care hospital services.

Campaigner John Palethorpe said: "The outcome of the services and opening hours offered is totally unclear. So far there are more questions than answers and we are not informed as to what we might gain or might not gain.

"We certainly know what we will lose ... firstly our GPs surgeries, a 60-year-old tried and tested service, giving satisfaction to thousands of patients daily, and, secondly, services at our local hospital.

Under the proposals, many services will be moved in to these super surgeries, thereby downgrading the hospital and losing other services to bigger hospitals in Leeds, York, Hull and Middlesbrough. As these hospitals are now running at capacity, waiting times and journey times will increase."

Fellow campaigner Mel Rogers, 66, of Snainton, said: "I am thoroughly disgusted that these super surgeries are being forced upon us by the PCT without proper area wide consultation."

Dave Willis, 71, who has been using his GP surgery in South Cliff since 1952, said: "I would urge everyone to say a firm no to all the PCTs proposals – they are neither needed nor wanted.

"This is just another way for the PCT to eventually save money by herding us like cattle on to a medical fast-track conveyor belt."


The full article contains 394 words and appears in Scarborough Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 16 May 2008 9:06 AM
  • Source: Scarborough Evening News
  • Location: Scarborough
 
Prev
1
2
1

badger464,

16/05/2008 09:39:42
personally i don't know enough about this new clinic to say if it is a good idea or not, what i would do is listen to the views of doctors and other professionals already supplying healthcare in scarborough, i'm sure they know best so i'd tend to go along with what they advise.

what i would like to see though is the SEN rather than just sitting on the fence and reporting such articles providing some means so that people can petition more effectively
2

Lady Taurus ,

Scarborough 16/05/2008 10:16:39
Badger: The SEN has covered the proposed "Super Clinic" very well.

I think all residents will agree after reading all the town's Dr's concern's about the "Super Clinic", as reported in an earlier edition, it is not going to be a good thing for all us patients.
3

A name thats not in use!,

scarborough 16/05/2008 15:55:23
So far I have only read comments from the older generation who have the time too wait for appointments or wait in waiting rooms. It would be interesting too hear the views of the younger generation who are either working or have families too look after where time is money and school schedules have too be worked around!
4

A name thats not in use!,

scarborough 16/05/2008 15:55:44
So far I have only read comments from the older generation who have the time too wait for appointments or wait in waiting rooms. It would be interesting too hear the views of the younger generation who are either working or have families too look after where time is money and school schedules have too be worked around!
5

Harbour Bar,

16/05/2008 18:45:23
Lady T 1s more I have to say the SEN's coverage has been ... oh no better not say anything dont wanna get baned
6

Harbour Bar,

16/05/2008 18:47:53
Notice 2 they havent a Comment on this page for the dogs on beech story y ever not I wonder?

1 sided reporting at its best
7

badger464,

16/05/2008 19:02:52
well sorry dina saurus but i never noticed my GP's comment in any such article, so that kinda rubbishes your comment about all the concerns of all the towns doctors, and i'm actually starting to wonder if this proposed new clinic had to be organised from outside scarborough because of the drachonian views held by people not fit to make decisions of that nature because their only concern is how it benefits themselves
8

castle crusader.,

scarborough 17/05/2008 08:06:35
Say No to ’Darzi’ - super clinics

These much vaunted, NHS super clinics are not quite all they are purported to be, whilst offering a host of up to twenty different services, all under one roof, nothing is actually being proposed except that a building will appear, in all probability at great expense to the tax payer.

The outcome of the services and opening hours offered is totally unclear, so far there are more questions than answer’s; we are not informed as to what we may gain, or may not gain, as the case maybe.

We certainly know for a fact just what we will lose, firstly our GPs surgeries, a 60 year old tried and tested service, giving satisfaction to thousands of patients daily, secondly services at our local hospital, under the proposals many services will be moved in to these super surgeries, thereby downgrading our hospital and losing other services to bigger hospitals in Leeds, York, Hull and Middlesbrough, as these hospitals are now running at capacity, waiting times for treatment will increase, your journey to your appointment will increase, often up to sixty miles from home.

There are countless other reasons for this proposal being floored, surgeries where you must use the onsite pharmacy, operated by the biggest, private bidder, denying you any choice, services run by the private sector, making huge profits for their shareholders, denying you a choice, seeing the next available GP, instead of your own, denying you a choice, having to use council car parking facilities, in the town centre, costing a fortune and denying you choice, replacing a service that we need, with one that in all probability, we will not want, denying you a choice.

Centralisation in other sectors of the NHS has been an unmitigated disaster, modern, purpose built hospitals, now downgraded to no more than rehab units, with no A & E, no Maternity Services and no specialist clinics, this is the stark reality of a NHS Primary Care trust and hospital trust, saving money
9

castle crusader.,

scarborough 17/05/2008 08:10:18
Centralisation in other sectors of the NHS has been an unmitigated disaster, modern, purpose built hospitals, now downgraded to no more than rehab units, with no A & E, no Maternity Services and no specialist clinics, this is the stark reality of a NHS Primary Care trust and hospital trust, saving money instead of lives.

I received a letter from a lady only yesterday, stating that the idea of super surgeries is not in fact a new one, she left M-boro some 25 years ago, to live in Scarborough, she has been with the same GPs surgery ever since she arrived, the service is so good that despite moving four miles from the surgery, she refuses to change, this is what she said.

“When I was a kid in my home town middlesbrough, they decided to create a super medical centre in the cleveland centre, this led to a lot of our smaller GPs surgeries to close, then one by one our hospitals were closing, in total we lost five, so they could bung everything into the new captain cook hospital, which as you will know, was already inundated, what chance do we have of getting any proper treatment at any of the super schemes they plan for us. I support our local GPs and hope they take a firm stand on this, I also do not agree with this being done behind our backs, by a couple of PCT chosen, small minority groups choosing for all of us”.

In conclusion, we as a patient led group to ‘Save our local GPs Surgeries’ hope will join our campaign in fighting for our rights and retain our GPs services as we know them, it would appear there is much to lose and precious little to gain.


The campaign group desperately need a donation of photocopying from a local source, for petition forms and fliers, we will provide the artwork and we also require any offers of a venue to hold a public meeting (urgently).

We most warmly welcome the participation of any GPs, pharmacists and patients, in order to raise a petition.

For further information, please contact
01723 370794 or
e:mail jon
10

castle crusader.,

scarborough 17/05/2008 08:11:34
For further information, please contact
01723 370794 or
e:mail jonboy525@btinternet.com
or write to
SAVE OUR GPs SURGERIES CAMPAIGN
5, Maria’s Court Scarborough YO11 1HH
Prev
1
2

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.